New University
of Illinois study cites code-sharing and anti-trust
immunity enjoyed by allied airlines with lower airfares for consumers
flying two-carrier itineraries
Air Canada (AC.TO) and its Star Alliancepartners today cited the
findings of a recently released University of Illinois study on the
benefits of code-sharing and anti-trust immunity as further evidence of
the overwhelming customer benefits of alliances between airlines.
The study, based on international fare data compiled by the United
States Department of Transportation during the third quarter of 1999,
found that customers flying itineraries involving two allied carriers
benefited from lower fares. In the specific case of itineraries
involving two allied airlines that both code-share and hold U.S.
anti-trust immunity, the result was fares that on average were 27% lower
than fares where inter-airline (interline) pricing methods were
employed. The study also specifically credited Star Alliance airlines
with saving customers $100 million annually as a result of the
combination of code-sharing and anti-trust immunity that some members of
Star Alliance currently hold.
University of Illinois economist Jan K. Brueckner prepared the July 2000
study. Brueckner also predicted that if U.S. anti-trust immunity were
extended in the future to airlines within Star Alliance that do not
currently have it, an additional $20 million in annual savings would be
generated for passengers making two-carrier trips on airlines within
Star Alliance.
In the study, Professor Brueckner concluded that, ``In addition to
enjoying the convenience gains made possible by airline cooperation,
interline passengers reap substantial benefits in the realm of pricing,
paying substantially lower fares as a result of cooperative behavior.''
Brueckner also attributed much of the savings to the anti-trust immunity
held by several members of Star Alliance, saying ``The immunity enjoyed
by Star Alliance partners generates an aggregate benefit of about $80
million per year for interline passengers. Code-sharing among Star
partners yields a further annual benefit of around $20 million. Thus,
these two existing forms of cooperation generate a benefit for the
alliance's interline passengers of approximately $100 million per
year.''
Welcoming the results of the study, Air Canada Vice President,
Marketing, Danielle Poudrette said, ``These results clearly demonstrate
that in addition to the wider network access and seamless service
benefits that customers of Star Alliance have enjoyed for the past three
years, the anti-trust immunity held by members of Star Alliance results
in an attractive, competitive fare structure that benefits the
consumer.''
The study attributed fare reductions on itineraries involving two allied
airlines to three levels of cooperation:
LEVEL OF COOPERATION PERCENTAGE FARE REDUCTION
----------------------- -------------------------
CODE-SHARING 7%
ALLIANCE MEMBERSHIP 4%
ANTI-TRUST IMMUNITY 16%
------------------------------
TOTAL 27%
Brueckner's study was based primarily on itineraries that originate or
terminate in the United States and involve two allied airlines flying
across the Atlantic or between the U.S. and Canada, comparing them to
two-carrier itineraries from the same origin to the same destination on
carriers that do not hold anti-trust immunity. Star Alliance members Air
Canada, Lufthansa German Airlines, SAS Scandinavian Airlines and United
Airlines currently hold anti-trust immunity.
A full copy of the report can be obtained at www.brueckner-report.com.
Current members of Star Alliance members are: Air Canada, Air New
Zealand, All Nippon Airways, Ansett Australia, Austrian Airlines Group
(which comprises Austrian Airlines, Lauda Air and Tyrolean Airways),
British Midland, Lufthansa German Airlines, Mexicana, Scandinavian
Airlines System - SAS, Singapore Airlines, Thai Airways International,
United Airlines and VARIG Brazilian Airlines. The Star Alliance network
offers more than 9,200 daily flights to more than 800 destinations in
130 countries. Star Alliance's Internet address is www.staralliance.com.
NOTE : Professor Brueckner's study relied on United States Department of
Transportation data from the third quarter of 1999. The welfare
computations considered only those carriers who were members of Star
Alliance as of the summer of 1999. As a result, the savings do not
include the benefits of extending U.S. anti-trust immunity to carriers
who joined since that time, including All Nippon Airways, Austrian
Airlines Group (which comprises Austrian Airlines, Lauda Air and
Tyrolean Airways), British Midland, Mexicana or Singapore Airlines.
|